A medical device manufacturer usually carries products liability for devices and components used on or in patients, errors and omissions for parts that fail to meet specification, product recall, property and equipment coverage for clean rooms, machining and inspection equipment, workers compensation, and an umbrella sized to customer and distributor contracts. Component shops need much of it too.
Why products exposure runs heavier for devices
Products exposure runs heavier for medical devices because the product ends up on or inside a patient, so a failure can mean injury rather than inconvenience. A bracket that cracks in a conveyor stops a line. A component that fractures in an implant, a surgical instrument or a pump touches a person who is already vulnerable, and claims of that kind tend to be serious, slow to resolve and expensive to defend.
The exposure also lasts. A device can stay in service, or in a patient, long after it leaves your building, so the claim may arrive well after the work was done. That makes the trigger of your liability policy and the continuity of your coverage matter more than usual. A shop that switches carriers or lets coverage lapse should understand how older work is treated under each form.
Claims also spread. When a device fails, the patient’s attorneys commonly name the device maker, the distributor, and every supplier whose part might be involved. Even a shop that did nothing wrong can spend real money proving it, which is why defense cost often matters as much as any final judgment.
Where general liability stops for medical products
General liability is often where the gap starts, because many standard forms exclude or restrict products used in medical treatment. The restriction may appear as a specific exclusion, a classification the carrier will not write, or an endorsement added at underwriting that limits medical products. A shop that moved into medical work after buying its policy may not notice the change until someone asks.
For that reason, device makers often buy products liability from specialty markets that accept medical exposure, sometimes as a stand-alone policy and sometimes as part of a program built for life sciences or manufacturing. The difference between premises coverage and products coverage is covered in our comparison of products liability and general liability for manufacturers, so the point here is narrower. Ask your agent to show you, on the actual form, how medical products are treated, and do not rely on a certificate that simply lists a general liability limit.
Component supplier or finished-device maker
Where you sit in the supply chain changes how an underwriter reads your shop. A finished-device maker designs the device, owns the label and sells it, so it carries the full products exposure and usually the design exposure that comes with it. A contract manufacturer or machine shop making components to an OEM’s print carries a narrower exposure, centered on whether the part was made to specification.
Narrower does not mean small. Underwriters commonly ask what the component does, whether it is implanted, whether it contacts the body, whether it is life-sustaining, and whether a failure would be obvious or hidden. A housing for a diagnostic cart and a feature on a spinal implant are both medical components, but they are underwritten very differently.
The line also moves. A shop that starts suggesting design changes, selecting materials, or assembling and packaging finished devices is taking on more of the device maker’s role, and the program should follow. Our page on manufacturing operations explains how we look at that shift when a shop’s work changes.
Errors and omissions when a part misses spec
Errors and omissions coverage is built for the loss that follows a part that misses specification but has not hurt anyone. If a lot of components is out of tolerance, the OEM may scrap assemblies, rework inventory and lose production time, and products liability usually does not respond because there is no injury or damage to other property.
Manufacturers errors and omissions is designed around that kind of financial loss to a customer. It is commonly written on a claims-made basis, so retroactive dates and continuous coverage matter. Many forms exclude contractual penalties, delay and the cost to redo your own work, and the wording varies a good deal between carriers. For a medical component shop, the useful question is whether the form responds when a customer’s inspection catches the problem before any device reaches a patient.
Real-World Scenario: A machine shop turns stainless components for a surgical instrument maker. A tool offset drifts during a long run, and the customer’s incoming inspection finds part of the lot out of tolerance after some pieces have already been built into instruments. Nobody is hurt, but the customer tears down the assemblies, quarantines inventory and sends the shop a demand for its costs. The shop’s liability policy does not respond because there is no injury, and the claim turns on whether its errors and omissions form covers a customer’s financial loss from parts that missed the print.
Recall and the records underwriters look for
Recall coverage pays for pulling product back, a cost that products liability usually leaves out. For devices, that can mean notifying hospitals and distributors, shipping product back, inspecting and destroying it, and replacing it. Our page on product recall coverage explains how the policy is structured, and the article on what product recall insurance covers walks through the costs that commonly fall inside or outside it.
Component shops face a version of the same exposure. When an OEM recalls a device because of a supplied part, it often looks to that supplier for its costs. Some recall forms address the customer’s recall expenses, and many do not, so the definitions decide.
Records shape both the claim and the underwriting. Underwriters for medical work commonly ask about your quality system, lot traceability, material certifications, inspection records and how you handle nonconforming parts. A shop that can trace a lot back to its raw material and its machine is easier to underwrite and much easier to defend. Our article on quality certification for machine shops covers how a documented quality system is built, and in medical work that paperwork is part of the insurance submission.
Clean rooms, sterilizers and outside processors
Property coverage for a device maker has to reach equipment that a general machine shop may not have. Clean rooms, controlled environments, inspection and measuring equipment, laser markers and packaging lines can hold a great deal of value, and a loss of environmental control can ruin inventory without any fire at all. Ask how the property policy treats contamination, spoilage, mechanical breakdown and the cost to requalify a room after a loss.
Much of the work also leaves your building. Parts go to sterilization contractors, platers, passivation and heat treating vendors, and finished goods may sit at a distributor. Many property forms cover only listed locations, so property at an outside processor or in transit may need an off-premises extension or an inland marine form. Customer-supplied material and implants in progress raise the same question about property of others.
Workers compensation follows the people who run the floor. Machine operators, assemblers, clean room staff and inspectors carry different hazards, from amputations and repetitive motion to chemical exposure in cleaning and passivation. The policy is written on payroll and classification, so accurate class codes matter. Our page on workers compensation covers how that coverage is placed.
In the patient’s hands
Products liability for devices and components
Often placed with specialty markets that accept medical exposure
When a part misses spec
Errors and omissions for a customer’s financial loss
Rework, scrapped assemblies and teardown costs
When devices come back
Product recall for notification, retrieval and replacement
Some forms address the customer’s recall costs
On your floor
Property for clean rooms, machines and inspection equipment
Workers compensation for operators, assemblers and inspectors
OEM contracts, additional insured status and the umbrella
OEM and distributor contracts usually decide how high the program has to go. Supply agreements commonly set minimum limits for products liability, general liability and umbrella, and many also ask for errors and omissions, recall, waivers of subrogation, primary and noncontributory wording, and additional insured status for the OEM. Read the agreement before you quote the job, not after the purchase order arrives.
Additional insured status is where a certificate and a policy can part ways. The endorsement on your policy decides whether the OEM is covered for products claims, completed work or only ongoing operations. Our article on additional insured status for manufacturers explains the endorsement types and what customers usually ask for.
An umbrella policy sits above your products, general liability, auto and employer’s liability limits, and it is usually how a device shop reaches the totals in its contracts. Confirm that the umbrella follows the medical products coverage underneath it, because some umbrella forms carry their own medical products exclusion. Device makers that sponsor or supply product for clinical studies often need clinical trial liability as well, which is a separate specialty coverage.
If you want us to review your program against your device work and your customer contracts, send us your details: what you make, whether it is a component or a finished device, the processes you send out, and the supply agreements you have signed.