The coverage gaps machine shops most often miss are customer parts and material in their care, tooling and parts sitting at outside processors, parts that are out of spec without hurting anyone, recall costs, and business income that runs out before a long-lead machine is replaced. Aerospace work and customer contract terms add gaps of their own.
Customer parts and material in your care
Customer-supplied material on your floor is often the largest gap in a machine shop program, because general liability commonly excludes property in your care, custody or control. A forging clamped in your fixture is about as clear an example of that exclusion as a shop can offer, and many forms also exclude damage to the particular part you are working on.
Standard property policies are usually written around your own business personal property. Many include only a small built-in amount for property of others, and that amount may not apply while the part is being processed or when the cause is a machine failure or a programming error. Shops that run expensive customer material, such as aerospace alloys or castings that have already been through several operations, can outgrow that built-in amount on a single job.
What usually closes this gap is a scheduled property-of-others limit or a bailee-type inland marine form, set against the most valuable collection of customer material likely to be on the floor at once. Our article on equipment failure that damages customer parts walks through how those forms respond when a spindle or controller fails mid-cut.
Tooling and parts at outside processors
Property that leaves your building is a common blind spot, because many property forms cover only the locations listed on the policy. Parts out at a heat treater, a plater, an anodizer or a grinder, and your own fixtures or dies sent along with them, may sit outside the coverage the moment they are loaded on the truck.
Some forms add an off-premises or transit extension, but it is often sublimited well below what a full load of finished parts is worth. Outside processors also have their own terms, which commonly limit what they will pay for damage to work in their hands. That leaves the shop answering to its customer with little help from either the processor or its own policy.
What usually closes this gap is an off-premises extension with a realistic limit, a transit coverage that matches how parts move, or an inland marine form written to follow the goods. The details of how location and transit wording works sit on our property coverage page. List every outside processor you use and ask your agent where each is covered.
Out-of-spec parts that hurt no one
A batch of parts that misses tolerance, gets installed in a customer’s assembly and has to be pulled out is a financial loss without injury, and general liability often does not respond to it. Those forms are built around bodily injury and physical damage to other property, and they commonly exclude the cost to fix your own faulty work and loss of use of property that was not physically harmed.
The customer’s claim in that case is usually for teardown, rework, sorting, replacement and lost production. That is the territory of errors and omissions, sometimes written as manufacturers errors and omissions or professional liability. Many shops assume it only matters for engineering firms, and that assumption is where the gap opens. A shop that machines to a customer print still answers for whether the part conforms.
Our explanation of professional liability for machine shops covers how these forms are triggered and what they commonly exclude, such as contractual penalties or delay.
Recall costs after a defect is found
Recall costs are usually a gap because both general liability and products liability commonly exclude the cost of withdrawing, inspecting and replacing products from the market. The exclusion is often labeled as a sistership or recall exclusion, and it tends to apply whether or not anyone was hurt.
For a machine shop, a recall rarely starts with your own branded product. It more often starts with a customer that finds a defect in a component you supplied and pulls every unit in the field that contains it. The customer then looks back up the supply chain for the cost of notification, shipping, disposal and replacement. Contracts commonly put that cost on the shop.
What usually closes this gap is a stand-alone product recall policy, and the wording varies more than most coverages. Our guide to what product recall insurance covers explains the usual cost categories and triggers.
Business income that ends before the machine is back
Business income coverage commonly runs out before a shop is fully back in production, because the limit or period of restoration was set against a quick repair rather than a real replacement. A large horizontal mill, a multi-axis machining center or a specialized grinder can carry long lead times, and installation, rigging, calibration and first-article approval add more.
Even after the machine is running, customers who moved work elsewhere may not come back right away. Many forms stop paying when the property is repaired or should have been repaired, unless an extended period of indemnity is added. Equipment breakdown losses also raise the question of whether downtime from a mechanical failure is covered at all under the property form.
In your care
Customer parts and material on your floor
Often outside general liability and thin on property
Away from your shop
Tooling and parts at outside processors
Often outside forms tied to listed locations
No one was hurt
Out-of-spec parts and recalls
Usually errors and omissions or recall, not liability
After the loss
Business income that ends too soon
Restoration period shorter than machine lead times
What usually closes this gap is a business income limit and period built from your actual lead times, an extended period of indemnity, and equipment breakdown coverage that includes downtime. Our article on business interruption for manufacturers covers how to size it.
Real-World Scenario: A precision shop loses its main multi-axis machining center to a fire in the electrical cabinet. The building damage is modest and the property claim moves quickly. The replacement machine, though, has a long build queue, and rigging and calibration add more time after it arrives. The business income coverage was set around a short repair, and it stops paying while the shop is still subcontracting its best customer’s work at a loss. Several of its regular jobs have moved to a competitor by the time the new machine is cutting parts.
Aircraft products exclusions on aerospace work
Shops that machine precision parts for aerospace often find that their general liability excludes or restricts products installed on aircraft. Some forms carry the exclusion from the start, and some add it by endorsement once the carrier learns what the shop makes. Grounding liability, the cost when aircraft are taken out of service over a suspected defect, is usually missing from standard forms entirely.
The gap tends to catch shops that drifted into aerospace work gradually, or that make simple brackets and fittings they assume are not aircraft parts. Many forms define the exposure by where the part ends up, not by how critical it is.
What usually closes this gap is aviation products liability from a specialty market, often with excess limits above it, plus errors and omissions and property-of-others limits that fit costly aerospace material. Our piece on aerospace and defense manufacturing insurance explains the aircraft wording to look for.
Products limits below what contracts require
Your products limits can be lower than what your customers’ purchase orders and supply agreements require, and many shops do not find out until a certificate request is rejected or a claim exceeds the policy. Customer terms commonly ask for specific products and completed operations limits, additional insured status, waivers of subrogation and primary wording.
Contract indemnity can also reach further than the policy. A purchase order may have you defend and hold harmless the customer for losses your insurance does not treat as insured contract, leaving the shop answering from its own balance sheet.
What usually closes this gap is reading the insurance and indemnity clauses before you sign, adding umbrella coverage where limits fall short, and confirming the endorsements match the contract. Our guide to what manufacturing customers require lists the clauses that tend to travel with orders.
A short self-check for your program
You can find most of these gaps yourself by tracing a real job through your policies with the wording open. Use your most valuable customer job and work down this list.
- Is customer material covered while it is being machined, and is the limit enough for your largest job?
- Are parts and tooling covered at each outside processor and in transit?
- If a batch is found out of spec after shipment and nobody is hurt, which policy responds?
- Do you carry product recall coverage, and do your contracts make you pay for a customer’s recall?
- Does your business income period match the lead time to replace your most important machine?
- If you make aerospace parts, does your liability form exclude aircraft products?
- Do your limits and endorsements match what your largest customers’ terms require?
- Do employees run errands in their own vehicles, and does your program include hired and non-owned auto?
If any answer is unclear, that is the place to start. The way we review programs for machine shop operations follows this same walk through the floor. To have us check your program against how your shop actually runs, send us your details: the material customers supply, the processes you send out, the machines you depend on, and the terms your customers attach to their orders.