Coverage Explained

Equipment Failure Damaged Customer Parts: What Covers It?

A slender end mill held in a collet chuck above a workpiece clamped in a machine vise

When an equipment failure in your machine shop damages customer parts, the loss usually falls to coverage for property of others in your care, because general liability commonly excludes property in your care, custody or control, and equipment breakdown coverage is built around your own machine and downtime. Whether you carry it depends on the policy wording.

Sorting the loss into its separate pieces

A single machine failure usually produces several different losses, and each of them is answered by a different part of your program, or by none of it. Sorting them out early keeps you from reporting the whole event under the wrong coverage.

The machine itself comes first. A burned spindle, a failed drive or a shorted controller is usually an equipment breakdown question, and our explanation of what equipment breakdown covers and the page on machine and equipment coverage handle that side, so it is not repeated here.

Then come the customer’s parts and material that were in the machine or next to it when it failed. That is property of others in your care, and it is the subject of this article. Close behind is the cost to redo the job: new material, the machine time and labor to run it again, and any outside processing that has to be repeated.

Your own downtime is a separate piece, usually a business income question that depends on whether the cause of loss is covered. Our article on business interruption for manufacturers covers how that works. Last are the customer’s own losses downstream: a late delivery, a stopped assembly line, an expedite charge. Those are mostly governed by the contract between you.

The machine that failed

Repair or replacement of your equipment
Usually an equipment breakdown question

The customer’s parts on the machine

Property of others in your care
A property-of-others or bailee-type limit, if you carry it

Your downtime

Lost income and extra expense while the machine is down
Business income, if the cause is covered

The customer’s downstream losses

Late delivery and line stoppage at their plant
Mostly a contract question

Who usually answers for each part of the loss after a machine failure. Forms vary, so the policy wording decides. No figures are shown.

Why general liability often does not pay for the customer’s parts

General liability often does not respond to customer parts damaged inside your shop, even though the damage is to someone else’s property and you may well be responsible for it. The reason is in the exclusions, not in the insuring agreement.

Many forms exclude damage to personal property in the care, custody or control of the insured. A casting your customer shipped to you, clamped in your fixture and cut on your machine is about as clear an example of that as a shop can produce. The policy is written for damage you cause to property you do not hold, such as a forklift striking a visitor’s truck in the lot.

Many forms also exclude damage to the particular part you are working on when the damage arises out of that work, along with the cost to repair or replace work that was done incorrectly. Underwriters treat scrapped parts as a cost of doing business in this trade, which is why general liability is commonly a poor fit for this loss. Once a finished part leaves your building and causes injury or damage elsewhere, the analysis changes, and our comparison of products liability and general liability for manufacturers picks up there.

Report the loss anyway and let the carrier respond in writing. Wording differs, endorsements can change the result, and a written position is more useful than an assumption.

How shops usually insure customer property

Shops usually arrange coverage for customer parts as property insurance, written for the customer’s goods while they are in the shop’s hands. It commonly comes in either of a couple of forms.

The simpler route is a property-of-others limit on the property policy. Many property forms include a small built-in amount for property of others and allow a larger limit to be scheduled. This coverage usually follows the same causes of loss as the rest of the policy, which matters, because standard property forms often exclude mechanical and electrical breakdown and damage that results from processing or faulty work.

The other route is a separate inland marine form, often called bailee or processors-type coverage. These forms are written around goods that belong to customers and move through a shop, and some can be shaped to include parts in transit and at outside processors. They vary a good deal from carrier to carrier, so the label on the form tells you little. The definitions and exclusions tell you what it does.

Equipment breakdown forms deserve a look as well. Some extend to other property that a covered breakdown damages, including property in your care, and many limit that or leave it out. A crash caused by a programming or setup error may also not meet the form’s definition of a breakdown. Ask the question directly instead of assuming either way.

Questions to ask about a property-of-others limit

A property-of-others limit is only as useful as its wording, so the questions that matter are specific ones.

  • Is the property covered while it is being worked on? Some forms cover customer goods in storage but restrict or exclude damage that happens during processing.
  • Which causes of loss apply? Fire and theft are commonly included. Damage caused by a machine failure may or may not be, and the answer may sit in a breakdown or processing exclusion.
  • Is the limit enough? Set it against the most valuable collection of customer material likely to be on the floor at the same time, not against an average week.
  • How is the customer’s material valued? Some forms pay the customer’s cost for the raw material, and others recognize the value added by earlier operations. The valuation ideas in our guide to replacement cost versus actual cash value apply here too.
  • Does it follow the parts off premises? Parts on a truck, at a heat treater or at a plater are often outside a form that covers listed locations only.
  • Does payment depend on your legal responsibility? Some forms pay only when you are legally liable for the damage, and others pay regardless of fault.

Real-World Scenario: A job shop is finishing a run of customer-supplied forgings when a spindle bearing seizes mid-cut. The tool digs in and ruins the part in the fixture, and an inspection shows the parts just before it are out of tolerance as well. The owner reports the claim expecting the liability policy to respond, and the carrier points to the care, custody or control exclusion. The equipment breakdown coverage addresses the spindle. The forgings, which had already been through outside heat treating at the customer’s expense, turn on a property-of-others limit that had never been reviewed against a job of that value.

The customer’s downstream losses

The customer’s own losses after the failure, such as late delivery penalties, lost production or the cost of sourcing parts elsewhere, are usually a contract question first and often are not insured at all. Property-of-others coverage is generally about the parts themselves, not about what their absence costs your customer.

Start with the purchase order and any supply agreement. Those documents may make you answerable for delay or line-down costs, may limit damages to the value of the parts, or may say nothing. Terms that customers attach to their orders are often accepted without a close read, and our article on what manufacturing customers require describes the insurance clauses that tend to travel with them.

Errors and omissions coverage is sometimes a partial answer. Manufacturers errors and omissions is built around a customer’s financial loss from a mistake in your work, without injury or physical damage to other property. Whether a delay that traces to a machine failure fits depends heavily on the wording, and many forms exclude contractual penalties and delay in delivery. Our piece on professional liability for machine shops explains what that coverage is designed around, so treat it as something to ask about, not something to count on.

What to do right after the failure

Right after the failure, stop the job, preserve what happened, and bring in the customer and your agent before anything is scrapped. What you do in those early hours shapes how every piece of the claim is handled. For other gaps that surface the same way, see coverage gaps machine shops commonly miss.

  • Photograph the machine, the failed component, the tooling and each damaged part before the setup is torn down.
  • Pull the job traveler, the purchase order, inspection records and the program that was running.
  • Establish what the customer’s material was worth on arrival, including any prior processing they paid for.
  • Tell the customer promptly and plainly what happened and how many parts are affected.
  • Report to your agent under each coverage that might apply, and let the carriers sort out which responds.
  • Keep the failed component and the damaged parts until the adjuster releases them. A scrapped part cannot be inspected, and the customer may have its own instructions for its property.

Avoid promising the customer payment or admitting responsibility for downstream costs before the carrier has weighed in, because many policies restrict commitments made without the carrier’s consent.

Checking your program before a loss

The time to answer these questions is before a failure, with the policies open and a real job in mind. Pick the most valuable customer job you run and trace it through the program.

Ask your agent to show you the wording that would respond if a machine failed mid-cut on that job: where customer property is covered, what causes of loss apply, what the limit is, and how the parts would be valued. Then follow the same parts to the outside processors you use and onto the truck. Compare the result with what your largest customers’ terms say you owe them for damaged material and for delay.

Revisit it when the work changes. A new customer that supplies expensive material, a move into larger parts, or a new outside process can outgrow a limit that was adequate when it was set. The way we approach coverage for machine shop operations starts with that kind of walk through the floor.

If you want a second set of eyes on how your program treats customer property, send us your details: the material customers supply, the processes you send out, the machines the work depends on, and the terms your customers attach to their orders.

The bottom line

Customer parts ruined by a machine failure are usually a property-of-others question, not a general liability or equipment breakdown question, so a shop should confirm before a loss that it carries that coverage, that it applies while parts are being worked on, and that the limit matches the most valuable job on the floor.

Frequently asked questions

Does general liability cover customer parts damaged in my shop?

Usually not. Many general liability forms exclude damage to property in your care, custody or control, and they commonly exclude the particular part you are working on when the work goes wrong. Customer material sitting in a vise or on a pallet in your building tends to fall inside those exclusions. Coverage for it is usually arranged as property of others, so check your property or inland marine wording.

Does equipment breakdown cover the parts that were on the machine?

Sometimes, but do not assume it. Equipment breakdown coverage is built around your own machine and the downtime that follows a mechanical or electrical failure. Some forms extend to other property the breakdown damages, including property in your care, and many limit or leave that out. Ask your agent to show you where the form addresses customer property, and whether your loss counts as a breakdown at all.

What is bailee or property-of-others coverage for a machine shop?

It is coverage for property that belongs to someone else while it is in your shop. It is often written as a property-of-others limit on the property policy, or as a separate inland marine form sometimes called bailee or processors coverage. The form decides which causes of loss apply, whether parts are covered while being worked on, how they are valued, and whether transit and outside processors are included.

Who pays for the customer’s material if my machine crashes?

It depends on your contract with the customer and on whether you carry coverage for property of others that applies to that kind of loss. A crash caused by a programming or setup error may not be treated the same as a mechanical or electrical failure, and many forms exclude damage from faulty processing. Without applicable coverage, the cost commonly lands on the shop, so read the wording before a loss.

Does my policy cover customer parts at an outside heat treater or plater?

Not automatically. Many property forms cover property only at the locations listed on the policy, so parts sent out for heat treating, plating or grinding may be outside the coverage unless the form extends to other locations and to transit. Some inland marine forms are built to follow the parts. Ask whether the extension exists, what limit applies, and what the processor’s own terms say about responsibility.

Do I owe the customer for their lost production?

That depends mostly on the contract, not on your insurance. Purchase order terms may make you answerable for late delivery or a line stoppage, or may limit what the customer can recover. These financial losses are often not insured under property or general liability forms. Errors and omissions coverage may respond in some situations, depending on the wording, so review both the contract and the policy.

About the author

Nate Jones, CPCU

Nate Jones, CPCU, is the founder of Wexford Insurance and Machine Guard Insurance, a specialty insurance agency placing machine shop and manufacturer coverage in 48 states across a 20-carrier specialty panel. He places property, inland marine and equipment breakdown coverage for machine shops that run customer-supplied material, so he works through who answers for a customer’s parts before a spindle or a controller ever fails. Connect via the Machine Guard Insurance quote form or call 317-942-0549.

Insure your shop or plant with a CPCU-led agency

Tell us what you machine or make — a job shop, a product manufacturer, or both — and we will market it to carriers that write the class.