Coverage Explained

Packaging Plant Insurance: Coverages Plants Should Review

A cutting tool in a machine spindle poised above a workpiece held in a vise

Packaging plant insurance is a program built around the plant, the lines, and the product: property coverage for a building full of combustible stock, equipment and income coverage for lines that cannot sit idle, and liability for the packaging you ship into your customers’ products. Which piece matters most depends on what you make and what it holds.

Why property is the first conversation

Property comes first because a packaging plant stores a great deal of material that burns. Corrugated and paperboard, rolls of film, resin, labels, pallets, and finished goods waiting to ship are all fuel, and they tend to be stacked high and close together. Metal and glass container makers carry less of that load in the product, but the cartons and shrink wrap around it bring much of it back.

An underwriter looking at your property coverage will usually ask how stock is arranged: rack or floor storage, pile heights, aisle widths, and whether roll stock and idle pallets are kept away from production. Sprinkler design matters as much as sprinkler presence, because a system laid out for an earlier tenant or a lower storage arrangement may not suit what is in the building now. Housekeeping counts too: paper dust, trim scrap, and film offcuts build up around converting equipment, and an inspector will ask how often they are cleared.

Many property policies for this class carry protective-safeguard conditions. In practice these often make coverage, or a part of it, depend on keeping a listed protection such as the sprinkler system or an alarm in working order and reporting when it is impaired. The exact effect depends on the policy wording, so read the condition, know who in the plant is responsible for impairment notices, and tell your agent before a system is shut down for work.

The lines that have to keep running

A packaging plant earns its revenue on a small number of lines, and a single failed machine can stop the building. Corrugators and converting equipment, printing presses, extrusion and thermoforming lines, bag machines, and filling lines are each a chain of drives, controls, and heated or pressurized components. When a main drive or a control cabinet fails, the cause is usually mechanical or electrical, and a standard property form often does not treat that as a covered cause of loss.

That is the reason to review equipment breakdown alongside property. Our page on machine and equipment coverage describes how the fixed side is structured, and the article on what equipment breakdown covers explains the kinds of failure these forms are usually written for.

The repair bill is often the smaller part of the loss. Replacement parts for specialized packaging machinery can carry long lead times, and a customer with a launch date will not wait on them. Business income coverage is usually the piece meant to answer for lost earnings, and how it is triggered, how long it runs, and whether it follows an equipment breakdown as well as a fire all depend on the form. We go through that in business interruption for manufacturers.

Dependence on others belongs in the same discussion. A plant that sells most of its output to a single key customer, or buys its board, film, or resin from a single mill or supplier, can lose income from a fire that happens at someone else’s location. Some policies offer contingent business income extensions for that situation, often with their own conditions, so ask whether yours does.

When packaging fails inside a customer’s product

Packaging is a product, and when it fails the loss usually appears in what the customer put inside it. A seal leaks, a closure backs off, a label carries the wrong ingredient statement or the wrong lot code, or an ink or adhesive taints the contents. Which coverage responds usually depends on the kind of harm.

If someone is hurt, or the customer’s goods are physically damaged, the claim is commonly handled under products liability, which usually sits within or beside general liability. Forms vary on how they treat damage to a product your packaging has become part of, so do not assume the answer. Our comparison of products liability and general liability for manufacturers covers that boundary.

If the customer has to pull filled product from warehouses or store shelves and replace it, that is a recall cost, and many liability forms exclude it. Recall policies also tend to separate your own expense to withdraw your packaging from the claim a customer brings for its expense, and a packaging maker is usually most exposed to the second. Check that the form you are offered addresses it. The product recall page explains the structure, and product recall versus product liability shows where each stops.

If nothing is injured or damaged but the packaging simply does not perform, such as film that will not run on the customer’s equipment or cartons printed in the wrong color, the customer’s loss is financial. That is commonly the territory of manufacturers errors and omissions, again subject to its own wording and exclusions.

Food-contact packaging, and packaging for drugs, cosmetics, or other regulated products, raises the stakes because the contents are eaten or used on the body. The FDA publishes an explanation of how it regulates substances that come into contact with food, and underwriters will ask whether your packaging is used that way.

Real-World Scenario: A flexible packaging plant ships printed pouches to a snack maker. After the pouches are filled and distributed, the snack maker finds that a seal on part of the run opens in transit. Nobody is hurt, but the customer pulls the affected lots from its distributors and sends the plant a claim for the product, the freight, and the replacement run. The plant’s liability carrier points to a recall exclusion, and the owner learns that the question was never whether the plant had liability coverage, but which kind of loss its policies were written to answer.

The plant

Building, stock, and finished goods
Property coverage and its protective conditions

The lines

Converting, printing, and filling equipment
Equipment breakdown and business income

The packaging you ship

Injury, damaged contents, or a recall at the customer
Products liability, recall, errors and omissions

The customer’s goods in your care

Product and materials you pack for others
Property of others

The layers of a packaging plant’s exposure and the coverage usually reviewed for each. Forms vary, so the policy wording decides. No figures are shown.

Contract packagers and goods that belong to the customer

A contract packager carries an exposure a converter does not: the customer’s own product is sitting in the plant. Bulk product waiting to be filled, customer-supplied bottles, cartons, and labels, and finished pallets awaiting pickup are all property of others in your care. Many general liability forms restrict coverage for property in the insured’s care, custody, or control, so damage to those goods is usually addressed by extending property coverage to property of others or by a bailee-type form. Set the limit against the most customer product you hold at once, not an average day.

Responsibility for a mislabel or a mis-pack is usually settled by the contract before it is settled by a policy. A packaging agreement may say who approves artwork, who verifies lot and date codes, who supplies the components, and who pays if filled product has to be reworked or destroyed. Indemnity clauses and insurance requirements often push that cost to the packager, sometimes further than its policies reach. Our article on additional insured requirements for manufacturers explains what those clauses typically ask for. Have your agent read the agreement before you sign it.

Workers compensation on fast lines

Workers compensation is usually the coverage that responds when an employee is hurt, and packaging plants give it plenty to respond to. Lines run fast, with nip points, cutting and scoring stations, heated sealing jaws, and jams that tempt an operator to reach in. Roll stock and pallets are heavy, so forklifts, clamp trucks, and manual handling account for much of the activity an underwriter wants to understand.

Expect questions about guarding, lockout practice, forklift training, and temporary labor during busy periods. Payroll classification and audit work the same way they do for other manufacturers, and our workers compensation page covers that structure.

Stock values that rise and fall with the season

Stock values in a packaging plant are rarely level, and a property limit set on an ordinary month can fall short at the peak. Plants serving produce growers, beverage makers, or holiday retail build inventory ahead of the season and ship it down afterward. If a loss happens at the high point and the limit reflects the low point, the shortfall is yours, and a coinsurance condition on the policy can reduce the payment further.

Carriers commonly offer a few ways to handle this. A reporting form bases the premium on stock values you report through the policy period, and it depends on those reports being accurate and on time. A peak-season endorsement raises the stock limit for a stated part of the calendar. Some plants simply insure to the peak all the time. Which fits depends on how sharp the swing is and how reliably you can report. Ask also how finished goods are valued, since some forms use cost and others can be endorsed to selling price.

What an underwriter will ask about your plant

An underwriter prices the plant from the description you give, so the questions are predictable and worth preparing for. Expect most of these:

  • What the packaging holds, and whether any of it touches food, drink, medicine, or products used on the body.
  • How raw material and finished goods are stored, and how the building is sprinklered, alarmed, and cleaned.
  • How many lines you run, whether a second line or a sister plant could take over a job, and how long key parts take to arrive.
  • What quality checks you run on seals, closures, print, and codes, and whether you can trace a lot of material to a lot of finished packaging and to the customer that received it.
  • Which contracts carry indemnity or insurance requirements.
  • What losses you have had and what changed afterward.

Answer them as the plant actually runs. A specialty carrier or a surplus lines carrier may be the right market for a plant with heavy storage or high-stakes contents, and a clear submission is what gets that plant considered. Our manufacturing insurance page gives the wider picture. When you are ready for a review, send us your details: what you make, what it holds, how you store it, and the contracts you have signed.

The bottom line

A packaging plant should review property and its protective conditions, equipment breakdown and business income for the lines, and products liability, recall, and errors and omissions for the packaging it ships, because a packaging failure usually shows up inside a customer’s product and the policy wording decides which coverage answers.

Frequently asked questions

What insurance does a packaging plant need?

Most packaging plants review property, equipment breakdown, business income, general liability with products coverage, and workers compensation as the core program. Plants whose packaging holds food, drink, or personal care products often add recall and errors and omissions to that list, and contract packagers look at coverage for customer goods in their care. Which of these a given plant carries depends on its contracts, its customers, and the policy forms offered.

Does general liability cover packaging that fails and ruins my customer’s product?

Sometimes, and it depends on the kind of loss and the policy wording. General liability with products coverage is usually built around bodily injury and physical damage to someone else’s property. A customer’s cost to pull product back, or a purely financial loss from packaging that did not perform, is often excluded or restricted. Recall and errors and omissions are the coverages commonly reviewed for those gaps.

Do packaging manufacturers need product recall insurance?

It depends on what your packaging holds and what your contracts say, but many packaging makers should at least review it. If a faulty seal, closure, or label could force a customer to withdraw its product, that customer will often look to you for the cost. Many liability forms exclude recall expense, so a separate recall policy, with wording that addresses a customer’s claim, is usually where that exposure is handled.

Is a contract packager responsible for the customer’s product while it is in the plant?

Often yes, at least in part, and the contract usually decides how far that responsibility goes. Bulk product, components, and finished goods you hold for a customer are property of others in your care, which many liability forms treat narrowly. Property coverage extended to goods of others is the common answer, and the limit should reflect what is actually on your floor at the busiest point.

Why is property insurance hard to get for a packaging plant?

Property insurance is harder to place because a packaging plant holds a heavy load of combustible material in a single building. Paper, board, film, resin, and pallets stacked high can feed a fire that is difficult to control. Underwriters usually want detail on storage arrangement, sprinkler protection, housekeeping, and dust control before they offer terms, and plants that cannot document those points often see fewer options.

Does equipment breakdown insurance cover a packaging line?

Often yes, for sudden mechanical or electrical failure of equipment on the line, subject to the form. Equipment breakdown coverage is commonly written for drives, motors, controls, and similar machinery, and many forms can extend to the income lost while the line is down. Wear, gradual deterioration, and some types of equipment are usually treated differently, so read the definitions and exclusions against the machines you actually run.

About the author

Nate Jones, CPCU

Nate Jones, CPCU, is the founder of Wexford Insurance and Machine Guard Insurance, a specialty insurance agency placing machine shop and manufacturer coverage in 48 states across a 20-carrier specialty panel. He places coverage for converters, container makers and contract packagers, so he works through stock storage, line downtime and what happens when packaging fails in a customer’s product before a submission goes to an underwriter. Connect via the Machine Guard Insurance quote form or call 317-942-0549.

Insure your shop or plant with a CPCU-led agency

Tell us what you machine or make — a job shop, a product manufacturer, or both — and we will market it to carriers that write the class.